• Homepage
  • Destinations
  • About Me
  • Contact
facebook twitter pinterest instagram

Mum's Gone To …

Travel tales of an empty nester
  • Homepage
  • Destinations
  • About Me
  • Contact
Home  >  Blog  >  Review of Water for Elephants by Sara Gruen

Review of Water for Elephants by Sara Gruen

Trish Burgess Posted on09/07/201128/12/2016 Book reviews 7 Comments

 

It’s a cliche to say ‘Don’t judge a book by its cover’ but I’m afraid we all do. The original book cover for this novel is on the left and it appeals to me as it conveys intrigue, something a little vintage and there is a sense that this is a book of substance just with the words ‘a novel’ neatly printed after the title (yes, I’m a sucker for marketing).

Water for Elephants has now been made into a ‘major motion picture’ so the whole book cover has been given a revamp, complete with actors in soppy pose, an elephant to remind us it’s about elephants, twinkly lights and a random trapeze artist swinging about in the background (or is it a monkey? I can’t be sure).

It was this second version I was asked to read as part of the Love A Book online reading group initiated by Cara at Freckles Family so I was a bit ambivalent about it. If I’d been given the original book I would have lunged straight in.  However, despite the lack of lunging, I was well and truly drawn into the unfolding drama from the first page.

It is a love story, set in a travelling circus during the Depression in America, but it is so much more than just the tale of two lovers. Very enlightening, a previously unknown world of circus life at a particular time in history is brought to life. We are shown the exhausting, perilous existence of those working behind the scenes, away from the glitter and sequins of the performers.

Jacob Jankowski, a young vet who hitches a ride on the circus train, tells the story from the confines of his nursing home. He is now a very old man, but the circus is in town and his memories are sparked.

The pace of the story, rattling along like the circus train itself, makes for an effortless read but that is in no way a criticism: the author chooses her words with such care and precision there is no need for unnecessary description. I felt it lost its way a little in the second half (but I may just have been tired and picked the wrong time to continue reading)  but the ending was far better than I’d anticipated so I was left feeling very uplifted to the degree that I may well have cheered out loud.

I’m not really an animal lover, can’t think I’m much into circuses either but the vivid cast of characters, both human and animal, plus the excellent narrative by Sara Gruen, make this an unexpected pleasure to read. Give it a go this summer and transport yourself to the Big Top.

Previous Article The Gallery – Grandparents – Grandma Eileen
Next Article Bisse Racing in Bardolino

Related Posts

  • Book cover of Mother Hens showing pink glasses shaped like chickens

    Book Review: Mother Hens by Sophie McCartney

    30/05/2023
  • Meet Me in Monaco book

    Book Review: Meet Me in Monaco by Hazel Gaynor and Heather Webb

    07/09/2019
  • The Excursionist JD Sumner

    Review of The Excursionist by J.D. Sumner

    03/05/2017

7 Comments

  1. Steve Reply
    09/07/2011 at 9:08 pm

    I'll be looking for something new to read in a week or two… thanks for the recommendation!

  2. Trish @ Mum's Gone to... Reply
    09/07/2011 at 9:24 pm

    @Steve – Are you off on your hols soon? You never know, it might just float your boat. I was surprised at how enjoyable it was; I found the detail about circus life quite an eye-opener.

  3. MsCaroline Reply
    09/07/2011 at 11:03 pm

    Thanks for the review. This one was on my 'maybe' list to add to the Kindle in case I got through the two I downloaded for the flight too quickly(I didn't.) Like you, I was drawn to the original cover. Sounds like the perfect read for a rainy afternoon in Seoul!

  4. libby Reply
    10/07/2011 at 6:38 am

    Do you do the 'read the first few lines and then ask yourself if you want to carry on'? I have 8 books on my bedside table that I did that for and I haven't been hooked by any of them yet….and I really fancy a book I can 'fall into'….might look out for this one…ps am I the only one that thinks that RPats has a strange face??

  5. Jean Reply
    10/07/2011 at 7:58 am

    I'll have to add this to my "must read" list xxx

  6. Trish @ Mum's Gone to... Reply
    10/07/2011 at 9:47 am

    @Ms Caroline – It would be perfect. I always hesitate a little recommending a book as everyone's tastes are different but if you were toying with the idea then I'd say, yes.

    @Libby – It is very easy to fall into. I've been reading Human Traces by Sebastian Faulkes and it's taking me ages as the descriptions and storyline are too long. I picked up Water for Elephants and it was an immediate blast of readability, but very good writing too.
    Ps – He doesn't do it for me!

    @Jean – it's worth a look: have a read of the fist page in a book shop (as Libby suggests) and see if it grabs you.

  7. Lynn's Life Reply
    10/07/2011 at 1:23 pm

    the movie did not sound exciting 2 me.
    but ur review on the book makes me want 2 read it. the books r always better than the movie anyways.

Leave a Reply

Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Follow Me

Random Visits

  • Mum’s Gone to the Phallus Museum – Shiny Happy People Meme 21/01/2010
  • The Gallery – Dinan, France 05/05/2010
  • Flying High 08/06/2011

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
facebook twitter instagram pinterest youtube

Recent Posts

  • Fingal hotel in Leith harbour
    I’ve just come down from the Isle of Skye… 18/05/2025
  • View of yellow cube houses
    Uniworld Tulips and Windmills River Cruise: Rotterdam 02/11/2024
  • statues of three boys on harbour wall with man standing in between them.
    Uniworld Tulips and Windmills River Cruise: Dutch excursions 19/10/2024
  • the phrase 75 years written in flowers
    Uniworld Tulips and Windmills River Cruise: Keukenhof and Kinderdijk 11/09/2024

Recent Comments

  • Mr Trevor Smith. on Holbeach Discovery Trail: QR codes unlock the town’s history
  • Uniworld Tulips and Windmills River Cruise: Rotterdam - Mum's Gone To ... on Uniworld Tulips and Windmills River Cruise: Dutch excursions
  • Uniworld Tulips and Windmills River Cruise: Dutch excursions - Mum's Gone To ... on Uniworld Tulips and Windmills River Cruise: Amsterdam.
  • Uniworld Tulips and Windmills River Cruise: Keukenhof and Kinderdijk - Mum's Gone To ... on The Gallery – The Weekend – Spalding Flower Parade
  • Uniworld Tulips and Windmills River Cruise: Keukenhof - Mum's Gone To ... on Uniworld Tulips and Windmills River Cruise: Amsterdam.
  • Uniworld Tulips and Windmills River Cruise: Amsterdam. - Mum's Gone To ... on Review of The Seine Experience river cruise, U by Uniworld
  • Mum's Gone to Bavaria: Hintersee and the magic forest - Mum's Gone To ... on Mum’s Gone to Bavaria – Rambling around Ramsau
  • Mum's Gone to Bavaria - Rambling around Ramsau - Mum's Gone To ... on A few of ‘my favorite things’ in Salzburg

Contact Us

To contact me, please visit my Contact page.

I'm on Twitter. Find me as @mumsgoneto
I'm on Facebook http://www.facebook.com/mumsgoneto
Instagram - mumsgoneto
Pinterest - Trish Burgess
Google plus - +TrishBurgess


Designed by 79DESIGN

UK WordPress Support

Website by 79DESIGN, Lincolnshire Web Designer